Intro rates now through March 31, 2027 — Acquisition Review $1,495 (reg. $1,995).

Investing

Pittsburgh's Proposed 'Fair Share' Tax and the 2027 Budgets: What Rental Owners Should Watch in December

By Eddie Werner · · 6 min read

Status as of November 16, 2026: Bill 2026-1052 is a proposal in committee. Budgets are proposed, not adopted.

December is when Pittsburgh's tax picture for the next year gets locked in. This year there's an extra item on the agenda that affects anyone who lives in the city and owns rentals: a proposed 2% tax on unearned income. Here's what it would do, where the 2027 property tax rates stand, and the dates to put on your calendar.

The proposal: Bill 2026-1052

Councilmember Barb Warwick introduced Bill 2026-1052 on October 27, 2026. It would add a new Chapter 248, "Unearned Income Tax," to the City Code. As of November 16, it's in committee. It was held for a public hearing on November 2, and an executive session was held November 10.

Based on the bill text posted on the City's legislative site:

  • Rate: 2% on the net unearned income of City residents, starting with the 2027 tax year. The bill lists an effective date of January 1, 2027.
  • Who pays: individuals domiciled in the city, including limited partners, S-corporation shareholders, and trust and estate beneficiaries. Corporations aren't included.
  • Rental income is included "irrespective of situs." That means a city resident's rentals outside the city would count too. The taxable amount is gross rents minus reasonable operating costs, including mortgage interest, repairs, depreciation, and real estate tax on the rental.
  • Rentals received in the conduct of a business that already pays the city's Earned Income or Net Profits Tax are excluded.
  • Gains from selling real estate and other property are included. For property received by gift or inheritance, the cost basis is the fair market value at acquisition or January 1, 2027, whichever is later.
  • Also included: dividends, certain royalties, and trust and estate distributions.
  • Excluded: interest, and retirement and pension payments, along with other listed items.

If you don't live in the city but own rentals here, this bill as written doesn't tax you, because it applies to city residents.

The open questions

This is a proposal, and it has real questions attached. I'm reporting them without taking a side:

  • Legal authority. TribLive reported that a 2024 City Law Department opinion called the city's authority to tax unearned income "not settled law." Several council members have said they expect a court challenge. Supporters, including a municipal lawyer at Warwick's briefing, say the city has the authority.
  • Timing. Warwick has acknowledged a legal challenge likely wouldn't be resolved in time to collect the tax in 2027. Mayor Corey O'Connor told WPXI he has "questions of the legality" and isn't counting on the revenue.
  • Revenue estimate. The Keystone Research Center estimated about $51 million a year, according to WTAE. That's a projection, not a city figure.
  • Details. A Schneider Downs analysis noted parts of the ordinance need clarification, including how partnership income would be treated.

The 2027 property tax rates

The property tax side looks steadier, but nothing is final until each body votes.

  • City of Pittsburgh: Mayor O'Connor's proposed 2027 budget keeps the rate at 9.67 mills, the rate since City Council raised it from 8.06 mills in December 2025. Council's budget office has raised concerns about the plan's use of about $28 million from reserves and a $10 million cut to pension funding. Council can amend the budget before it votes.
  • Pittsburgh Public Schools: the preliminary 2027 budget projects $739.7 million in spending and an operating deficit of about $13.7 million, and it does not include a millage increase. The current school rate is 10.457 mills. The district has certified it won't exceed its 3.5% Act 1 cap.
  • Allegheny County: County Executive Sara Innamorato's proposed 2027 budget keeps the county rate at 6.43 mills, with no increase.

December dates to watch

DateWhat happens
Wed., Dec. 9Pittsburgh Public Schools special budget hearing
Thu., Dec. 10, 10 a.m.City Council public hearing on 2027 tax and budget bills and Bill 2026-1052. Speaker registration closes at 8 a.m. that day.
Tue., Dec. 15, 1:30 p.m.City Council's scheduled line-item vote on the 2027 budget
Fri., Dec. 18URA deadline for 2027 LIHTC pre-applications (see below)
Wed., Dec. 23PPS board's scheduled vote on its 2027 budget and tax rates

You can register to speak through the City Clerk's Office at 412-255-2138 or online, or send written comments to cityclerksoffice@pittsburghpa.gov.

For affordable-housing developers: the Urban Redevelopment Authority's 2027 Low-Income Housing Tax Credit pre-application is due December 18, 2026. It's required for 4% or 9% LIHTC projects that want a preliminary commitment of URA funds or site control of publicly owned land. URA's two pages list different cutoff times (4 p.m. and 5 p.m.), so plan for the earlier one.

What I'd do now

  • City residents: total your 2026 net rental income and any planned 2027 sales so you know what 2% of it would be if the tax took effect.
  • Talk to your CPA before restructuring anything, because the bill's treatment of partnerships and LLCs isn't fully clear.
  • Keep clean books: operating costs, mortgage interest, and depreciation records would reduce the taxable amount.
  • Underwrite 2027 with current millage, but stress-test a higher rate. Last year's 20% city increase passed on December 21.
  • Watch the Dec. 10 hearing and the Dec. 15 and Dec. 23 votes. We'll post an update when they happen.

How PRC helps

Taxes are one line on your operating statement, and a line that can move. A Desktop Deal Screen sanity-checks a property's numbers, including taxes, before you make an offer. An Acquisition Review goes deeper on operating costs and risks before you close. If you already own and the numbers are getting tight, Stabilization & Turnaround Advisory helps you rebuild the plan.

Questions about how this affects your portfolio? Book a free 20-minute discovery call.

Sources


This article is general information for property owners, not tax or legal advice. Bill 2026-1052 is a proposal and may change, fail, or be challenged in court, and the 2027 budgets aren't final. Consult a CPA or tax attorney about your situation.

Want a second set of eyes on your rental?

Talk with Eddie about your property, your concerns, and the right next step.

Book a free 20-minute discovery call

Related insights

Investing

Pittsburgh's New Zoning Rules: ADUs and No Parking Minimums

· 5 min read

Pittsburgh's biggest zoning change in decades took effect Oct. 29. Backyard and in-law units are easier to add, parking minimums are gone, and larger projects can earn height for affordable units. Here's what matters for small investors.

Read more
← All Pittsburgh Insights